Mamma Mia! Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of Foley, Alabama, at 246 W Laurel Ave, Mamma Mia! Pizzeria brings a slice of authentic Italian-American comfort to the Gulf Coast. This cozy, family-friendly eatery combines the warmth of a neighborhood pizzeria with the charm of a casual dining spot, offering handcrafted New York-style pies, hearty pasta dishes, and Italian sandwiches made with house-baked bread. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita pizza or a loaded meatball sub, the menu reflects a commitment to quality, with dough tossed fresh daily and sauces simmered to perfection.

The story of Mamma Mia! Pizzeria is rooted in passion and community. Founded by Nicole, a seasoned restaurateur with a vision to create a gathering place for Foley’s growing population, the pizzeria occupies a revitalized space that once housed a local Dairy Queen. The stone-clad exterior and inviting outdoor seating area provide a relaxed atmosphere where guests can enjoy their meals under the Alabama sky. Inside, the intimate dining room buzzes with the aroma of garlic, melted cheese, and wood-fired crusts, creating an ambiance that feels both nostalgic and refreshingly modern.

Specializing in New York-style pizza, Mamma Mia! takes pride in its hand-tossed crusts—thin, crispy, and sturdy enough to hold generous toppings without sacrificing the foldable quality that defines a true NYC slice. While some reviews note variations in texture, loyal patrons rave about the light, airy dough and the balance of flavors in signature pies like the pepperoni-laden classic or the veggie-loaded garden special. The menu also shines beyond pizza, featuring al dente pasta dishes tossed in rich marinara or creamy Alfredo, alongside sandwiches stacked with house-roasted meats and fresh produce. Don’t miss the homemade cheesecake, a creamy finale that regulars insist rivals nonna’s recipe.

What sets Mamma Mia! apart is its dedication to inclusivity and convenience. Vegetarian and vegan-friendly options ensure everyone finds something to savor, while takeout and delivery services via platforms like DoorDash make it easy to enjoy their offerings at home. The staff’s attentive service and the restaurant’s wheelchair-accessible layout further underscore its commitment to welcoming all guests. Open six days a week for lunch and dinner, the pizzeria has become a staple for locals celebrating birthdays, catching up over wine, or simply grabbing a quick yet satisfying meal.

As Foley continues to grow, Mamma Mia! Pizzeria remains a testament to small-town entrepreneurship and culinary passion. From its humble beginnings as a dream to its current status as a Tripadvisor Travelers’ Choice contender, the restaurant embodies the spirit of community through every bite. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular, the promise of a hearty meal, a friendly smile, and a taste of homemade Italian tradition awaits at this Laurel Avenue gem. For reservations or takeout, call +1 251-971-7492—and prepare to leave with a full stomach and a craving to return.